Coinkite CEO Rubs Salt in a $100M+ Coldcard Bitcoin Theft Wound

The latest comments by Rodolfo Novak (NVK), CEO and co-founder of Coldcard hardware wallet maker Coinkite, have drawn backlash. Novak said he had dedicated 18 years of his life to bitcoin adoption and that about 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected by thefts that drained more than $100 million in bitcoin. Recently, Novak also posted […]
Key Takeaways
• Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak said about 0.17% of Coldcard users were affected by its flawed firmware.
• Coinkite has not disclosed its sales figures or confirmed the number of affected users.
• Novak’s latest comments drew criticism from users who questioned his accountability following the losses.
Recently, Novak also posted that “Bitcoin won” and that his “industry tenure is done. Backseat from now…”, adding a victory hand emoji (his X account is now set to private, as of this writing).
Novak didn’t explain what he meant by his tenure being done or taking the “backseat,” including whether he plans to step down as Coinkite’s CEO. However, the post drew numerous critical replies, with multiple accounts pointing to the losses Coldcard users suffered beginning in July.
How Many Users Were Affected?
“Your industry tenure amounts to countless people losing a combined total of over 100mm dollars of Bitcoin. Great work,” X user secondbestdrew reacted, using an eye-rolling emoji.
Novak replied, “Yes, it sucks,” and added that “0.2% of Coldcard users were affected.” In a separate reply, the CEO explained that he had calculated this figure using “loss reports, public blockchain chain data, and internal production numbers.” He added that it was “actually closer to ~0.17[%].”
Production figures count devices made, not the people who own them. One person can own multiple Coldcards. Novak also didn’t clarify whether affected users means those who lost funds or everyone who created a wallet using the flawed firmware.
Coinkite declined to estimate losses in August and hasn’t published a figure since. Its sales numbers are also not public. In August, Coinkite told Bloomberg that the wallet’s privacy-focused design prevented the company from verifying loss estimates calculated by outside parties. Its own status page also states that “The public record does not provide a complete model-by-model victim ledger.”
Meanwhile, a separate, detailed technical postmortem is still being prepared. The first thefts were reported on July 30, more than three months ago.
About 1,830 BTC Stolen
In September, Alex Thorn, head of firmwide research at Galaxy, cited a total of 1,830 BTC stolen from about 9,200 addresses, with the funds currently valued near $116 million. Also, according to Thorn, of the 256 Coldcard victims who approached Galaxy, 245 of them owned 2,585 addresses holding a total of 895 BTC.
Meanwhile, in a proposed class action filed against Coinkite in Ontario in September, the plaintiff said he lost 1.229 BTC across seven addresses in a single wallet. Therefore, without Coinkite disclosing its internal data, the total number of affected users remains unknown.
Previously, Coinkite claimed that it did not store customer information. The company later said it had emailed every address it could reach through its store and newsletter systems.
For example, if Coinkite made one million devices, then 0.17% of them would represent about 1,700 affected users, assuming one device per user. That would mean one Coldcard for every eight devices sold by market leader Ledger, which says it has sold more than eight million. Ledger’s wallets support multiple crypto assets, while Coldcard is bitcoin-only.
More clarity might come from the courts. The above-mentioned class action seeks to represent everyone who bought an Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, Mk5 or Q Coldcard model directly from Coinkite for personal use. Novak and co-founder Peter Gray are also named as defendants. If the court allows the case to proceed as a class action, it may need to establish how many buyers there were.
Critics Dismissed as “Bots”
Reactions to Novak’s latest posts were largely critical, with replies calling the timing tone-deaf and accusing him of lacking accountability.
“Shouldn’t you be doing the opposite right now?” X user mR_sAt asked, reacting to Novak’s backseat plan and reminding him that many Coldcard users had suffered losses.
Some replies supported Novak and thanked him for his work. The CEO, meanwhile, dismissed some critics as “competitor’s bots.”
Bitcoin.com News contacted Coinkite for comment and will update the article if the company replies.
